Why SCHD Works — and When It Doesn’t
Why SCHD Works — and When It Doesn’t
By The Rational Edge
Process · Probability · Perspective
The Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD) has become a quiet favorite among disciplined investors. It offers yield without hype, structure without complexity, and performance without obsession. Yet no strategy—no matter how elegantly constructed—works all the time.
Most investors get this wrong.
They judge SCHD by short performance windows, comparing it to megacap tech or speculative surges. They see a stretch of underperformance and assume something is broken.
Nothing is broken.
SCHD is doing exactly what it was built to do.
You simply have to understand the environment, the design, and the time horizon.
This essay brings the full picture together:
why SCHD outperformed from 2011–2021
why it lagged from 2022–2024
why interest rates determine relative performance
why SCHD’s long-term growth mirrors nominal GDP
why 4–6% dividend growth + 4–6% price appreciation is the correct base case
why contributions and DRIP transform long-term outcomes
how income actually grows from year 1 to year 10
And finally:
What SCHD is, what it isn’t, and when it shines.
I. SCHD Begins With Something Enduring
Most investment strategies begin with clever narratives or complicated formulas. SCHD begins with something simpler and infinitely more durable:
Own consistently profitable companies that raise dividends and treat shareholders well.
Its formula is built on:
free cash flow
rising dividends
high return on equity
balance sheet quality
valuation discipline
Nothing exotic.
Nothing speculative.
Nothing designed to manufacture excitement.
Just quality companies producing real cash.
SCHD’s index enforces this discipline. Companies that cut dividends, weaken profitability, or overextend leverage are removed. Those that survive tend to show stability, conservative leadership, and a pattern of rewarding shareholders.
In practice, SCHD automates the behavior rational investors intend to follow but struggle to execute consistently.
II. The Overlooked Truth: SCHD Is Interest-Rate Sensitive
This is the central insight most investors miss:
SCHD’s relative performance is heavily influenced by interest-rate regimes.
To understand when SCHD shines—or lags—you must understand what interest rates are doing.
III. Why SCHD Outperformed in the 0% Interest-Rate Era (2011–2021)
From 2011–2021, interest rates hovered near zero.
Cash paid nothing.
Bonds paid very little.
Income was scarce.
In that world:
3–4% yields looked extraordinary
value stocks acted as bond substitutes
discount rates were low
steady cashflow was rewarded
dividend growth stood out
SCHD thrived because the macro environment amplified its strengths—profitability, free cash flow, and rising dividends.
This was not luck.
It was alignment.
IV. Why SCHD Lagged When Rates Spiked (2022–2024)
Then the regime changed—violently.
The Federal Reserve raised interest rates from 0% → 5% in record time.
This hit SCHD in three predictable ways:
1. Dividend yields suddenly competed with cash
When money markets pay 5%, a 3.5% dividend loses shine.
2. Higher discount rates compress value stocks
Dividends = cashflows
Cashflows = discounted
Higher discount rates = lower present value
This is exactly the environment where value and dividend strategies lag.
3. Growth stocks (the “Magnificent 7”) dominated
SCHD owns almost none of them by design.
SCHD did not “break.”
It simply behaved like high-quality value behaves during rising-rate, growth-led cycles.
V. SCHD’s Future Lives in a Normalized Rate World
Neither 0% nor 5% interest rates are the right baseline.
SCHD’s long-term expectation lives in the middle—
in a world where interest rates normalize to:
2.5%–3.5% fed funds
stable inflation
steady discount rates
earnings mattering more than narratives
cash yields something but not everything
This is where SCHD historically shines:
steady, boring, durable compounding.
VI. Why SCHD’s Growth Mirrors U.S. GDP
Here is the macro insight that ties everything together:
Large-cap corporate earnings grow in line with nominal GDP (4–6%/year).
Nominal GDP = real GDP (2–3%) + inflation (2–3%)
Because SCHD holds mature, cashflow-rich companies, its long-term earnings and dividends grow at similar speeds.
SCHD is not built to outrun the U.S. economy.
It is built to mirror it.
This is why SCHD’s long-term expectation—
4–6% dividend growth + 4–6% price appreciation—
is not just reasonable; it is mathematically grounded.
VII. The SCHD Base Case: 8–12% Total Annual Return
Combine the components:
4–6% dividend growth
4–6% price appreciation
→
8–12% long-term total return
Not exciting.
Not flashy.
But deeply reliable.
This is what SCHD is designed for:
not to beat QQQ, but to compound steadily for disciplined investors.
VIII. What SCHD Compounding Actually Looks Like (Real Numbers)
To understand what SCHD actually does for an investor over a decade, we need to see how portfolio growth and dividend income evolve over time.
Below we compare two realistic investor profiles:
Investor A: $500/month contribution
Investor B: $1,000/month contribution
Both start with $100,000, reinvest dividends (DRIP), and hold for 10 years.
We model both the 4/4 base case (8% total return) and the 6/6 strong case (12% total return).
Scenario 1: $500 Per Month Contribution
Ten-Year Portfolio Growth and Dividend Income
ScenarioEnding ValueYear 1 IncomeYear 10 IncomeDollar Growth4/4 Base Case (8% total)$298,000~$3,500~$5,200~$138,0006/6 Strong Case (12% total)$420,000~$3,500~$8,400~$260,000
Interpretation
Both portfolios start with the same income (~$3,500/year).
By year 10:
$5,200 (4/4 scenario)
$8,400 (6/6 scenario)
The stronger compounding engine generates $3,200 more income every year.
Same contributions.
Same discipline.
Different compounding environment.
Scenario 2: $1,000 Per Month Contribution
Ten-Year Portfolio Growth and Dividend Income
ScenarioEnding ValueYear 1 IncomeYear 10 IncomeDollar Growth4/4 Base Case (8% total)$456,000~$3,500~$8,000~$236,0006/6 Strong Case (12% total)$614,000~$3,500~$12,300~$394,000
Interpretation
With higher monthly contributions:
Ending income becomes ~$8,000 vs. ~12,300
Portfolio value becomes $456,000 vs. $614,000
The strong regime delivers $4,300 extra income every year and $158,000 more total wealth.
Again:
Same investor.
Same discipline.
Same behavior.
The difference is the long-term compounding engine.
IX. The Behavioral Insight Most Investors Miss
Investors obsess over what SCHD does this year.
But what actually matters is what SCHD builds over ten years.
It builds:
more shares
rising dividends
widening income streams
a stable compounding engine tied to the U.S. economy
a 10-year transformation of cash flow
The journey from:
$3,500 → $5,200 → $8,000 → $12,300
…is the story of SCHD.
The dividend-growth regime you experience determines your future income.
Your contributions determine how fast you get there.
Your discipline determines whether you stay long enough to see it.
X. When SCHD Will Lag (And Why That’s Okay)
SCHD will lag during:
speculative growth surges
AI narrative bubbles
rising interest rate shocks
mega-cap concentration periods
valuation melt-ups
This is not failure.
It is the cost of durability.
When conditions normalize—and they always do—profitability and cashflow take over again. SCHD’s filters ensure exposure to exactly those traits.
XI. Hidden Advantages Most Investors Forget
1. Tax Efficiency
In-kind reconstitution means no annual capital-gain distributions.
2. Qualified Dividends
A major advantage in taxable accounts.
3. Profitability-Weighted Indexing
SCHD tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index—
a rules-based filter for consistent dividend growers across the entire market.
4. A Behavioral Anchor
SCHD’s greatest gift may be that it encourages better investor behavior.
It is stable, boring, and predictable—qualities that help investors stay invested.
XII. SCHD Is a Cornerstone, Not a Universe
SCHD is:
U.S.-only
large-cap
dividend-gated
value-biased
It intentionally omits:
innovation
emerging markets
international stocks
megacap tech concentration
It’s not designed to be everything.
It’s designed to be the stable core.
Complement it.
Don’t idolize it.
Don’t abandon it in the wrong regime.
XIII. Why I Own SCHD
Not as a recommendation—
as alignment.
I invest in what matches my temperament:
structured
patient
dividend-focused
grounded in real cashflow
built for long horizons
immune to hype
SCHD lets me invest the way I think best.
It is not a miracle.
It is a method.
It rewards:
consistent contributions
reinvested dividends
emotional restraint
long-term thinking
It doesn’t offer fireworks.
It offers something far more valuable:
Clarity.
Predictability.
Time-tested compounding.
For most investors, that is the real superpower.
A rational investor can allocate a meaningful portion of a portfolio to SCHD, but not necessarily all of it. SCHD isn’t designed to be all things to all people all the time—it’s a cornerstone, not a universe. Its focus on dividend-paying value companies means certain areas, such as high-growth innovators or international exposures, are underrepresented. Depending on one’s goals, time horizon, and tolerance for volatility, SCHD can be thoughtfully complemented with growth-oriented funds or assets that capture what SCHD intentionally omits.
SCHD is not a miracle; it’s a method. It works because it encourages rational behavior—buying quality, holding through noise, and letting compounding do the heavy lifting. It doesn’t promise market-beating fireworks, but it offers something far rarer: clarity.
The information in this publication is for educational and informational purposes only. It is not investment, tax, or financial advice. Investors should do their own research or consult a professional before making financial decisions.
Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.